Siblings playing on a camera trap
Catherine Grady (Guest) · 25:28
Yeah. Um, so we weren't able to collar this year, but we still did put up camera traps. And one of my favorite things about this was we captured, um, two siblings that were likely dispersing from their mother cuz they were old enough and so they're now going to find their own territory. And on the camera trap pictures, they are these like snapshots of them like playing. And there's this hilarious photo of like, there's a big rock here and there's like a snow leopard in midair, and then the other one, and they're just like totally like siblings playing. And then the next one is a snapshot of like one of them standing and then the other one like nuzzling it just very sweetly. And that's the one that really stood out to me. Um, I think it, it just was like, oh, I, I just kind of was at a loss for words when I first saw it. It was just like this animal just clearly just loves its sibling and is just so safe and invested in the relationship. And I was like, my brother and I are like very, very close. And I was like, oh my God, that's, that's my brother and me. We're playing and then we're like, I love you so much. And, uh, yeah, I think, I think more people need to see that kind of thing. So that was really exciting.
Natalie Stockdale (Host) · 27:07
Yes. Yeah. Emotional intelligence of animals and, and the relationships of animals. A snowshoe Are snow leopards endangered?
Catherine Grady (Guest) · 27:17
Mm-hmm. Yeah, they're technically, I think they're being reassessed right now. Um, Mongolia has a pretty strong population compared to other nations, but, um, overall they're definitely vulnerable. Yeah, I think they're being reassessed, so I can't fully say yet, but I would assume yeah.
Natalie Stockdale (Host) · 27:37
All right. Katherine, you've worked across different continents and researching different species, are there any universal truths that you've discovered about animals' minds?
Catherine Grady (Guest) · 27:54
I think there are two things. The first thing is, um, that this kind of ties back into what I talked about, like the formative things I learned in my first few years studying biology and like the things that kind of challenge conventional norms of, um, which is, I think scientists, the common phrase for where an animal lives is habitat. And I think I've heard people start to use the term home. Um, which I think you even just that slight shift in language really helps you Reframe how you're investigating this animal. Um, and coming to another country and saying that, then I feel like you can really appreciate, oh my God, like this animal has lived here for so long and like has, like its ancestors have been here and then they're like these rainforests next door. Being destroyed and, you know, that's terrifying for anything if you call it habitat. But if you, if you call it home, I think saying things like that, you're really able to, like, it kind of makes me think of the hospitality culture in Mongolia. Like when you're able to slow down and appreciate, I'm in this animal's home, it has you know, welcomed me here. I'm like, this is a privilege. Then you're really able to kind of understand, um, what it needs and where it's coming from. So I think the first universal truth is that, um, I, I don't know if this is like a universal truth, but I think animals, just like, um, like, I, I don't quite know how to say this exactly, but it's just, you know, when you're doing international research, you're going into an animal's like home and it's a very vulnerable state for that creature to be in. And so I think just really reframing your mindset there is kind of I, more of a universal truth for me and something I recommend for other colleagues. But then something for, um, that I've noticed with animals is that animals are actually very curious and even if they're like prey and things like that. Um, and I definitely, I definitely noticed this as a child and, um, I think it kind of couples with the idea of like reframing your vocabulary, but, um, I think like even, even if it's like a prey species or something, if you're able to slow down, you can really observe their personalities a lot more. And so like if you think of like Like all animals are very curious and I think the universal truth here is that like they, everything just wants to be loved. Like there's a place for everything and, um, if you're able to slow down and just like see them for who they really are, then they will welcome you. Um, and I think, you know, that's why there are these photos of like Jane Goodall, like being really close with chimpanzees and things, because she didn't just jump in and like start writing down stuff. She really slowed down. And like, um, like working on a farm and there's like a really shy cow or whatever, I, um, I would sit, for example, um, this actually happened in Mongolia. I would basically like spend some time of my day just like sitting next to this little cow, um, at this one place we were staying. And like, at first it was very shy, but like, I wasn't asking anything from it. I just knew like, this thing is just worthy because it exists. And like, I don't, I'm not asking anything of it. I just wanna like learn more about you. Um, and I think when you're able to like do that, you can then eventually, like it came up to me and then it like put its head in my lap and like I was able to give it like scratches on its neck and like, and, um, I think the same thing goes for the wild world. Like, um, you know, they're. I think I've noticed that with all the things I've studied, whether like just like urban animals that are more used to humans or things that are a lot farther, um, into the dense backcountry, everything just wants to be loved, but they're all a little skeptical because of how much, um, we've instilled these like narratives founded in misinformation about them. But, um, when you go into a place and you just are patient and you just realize like, I'm in this animal's home and it just, it wants to be understood, then I feel like that's where you really have breakthroughs. Um, and so I think no matter What animal I'm studying, whether it's like a grizzly bear eating a carcass in Yellowstone or like, like a little freshwater fish in like the river in Belize, like everything just like, I don't think anything actually wants to harm you unless provoked. And I very much feel like that would growing up as well. Um, and so I think that— I think that is really just like the universal truth of like these animals are naturally very loving, no matter predator or prey. And I think that's what we need to change, especially in like the more public scene. I think a lot of scientists really already know this, but, um, yeah, that was a very long answer. So thanks for sticking with me there. Yeah.
Natalie Stockdale (Host) · 35:00
I was just thinking about what you said. Do you think there are some exceptions to what you said about all animals just wanting to be loved? I mean, I, I can understand that with mammals and birds, but what about reptiles? I'm thinking of crocodiles. Yeah, I guess that's a whole new topic, isn't it? I must interview a crocodile expert and to, um, ask about the emotional, uh, lives of crocodiles, if there is— if, if, you know, if there is such a thing, they do have emotional lives.
Catherine Grady (Guest) · 35:33
Yeah, yeah. I think, um, you know, I naturally feel very drawn to studying animals, but I think one of the— or sorry, not an— well, yes, animals, but mammals. Um, but I think where we can really challenge norms and things like that is with like reptiles and fish. And like, there's a reason people say like reptilian brain. It's not like a compliment, you know. Um, but I think, I think coming into this, um, that researching animals like those with this, uh, continuous questioning, like, how do we know that they're not smart? Like, how do we even measure intelligence? Like, just because they can't, like, solve, like, some calculus problem doesn't mean they're, like, automatically stupid. But I am very curious if there's more than meets the eye there. And I think this is very interesting with fish, especially because, um, I grew up, you know, working on farms and in my free time, like, my cousins and I would go fishing and I always hated it because I, I just, it just felt wrong. And like, there's a difference from fishing for sustenance versus like catch and release. I totally respect fishing for sustenance, like, nothing wrong with that, obviously. But when we were just catching something and releasing it, I just, it didn't sit right with me. And my professor, um, sometime last year was talking to me and she was saying there is research about how fish have PTSD. And I think that is really interesting to me because automatically it's like, I think some of the animals like lowest, um, on like the scale are like fish and like reptiles and like some like bold birds and like poultry and things like that. But like the fact that that kind of research has been done is like very exciting to me. And I feel like I already kind of knew that cuz I feel like I've held onto this belief that I had as a child where I saw animals as equals and that I think a lot of children have and you kind of lose that as you get older. And she was also explaining how fish get lonely. Um, and so having like a one goldfish in a bowl is like very bad for it. And you know, That makes sense. Like some people might take like a fully like by the book kind of approach of like, well, yes, this is probably because it evolved in, you know, swimming in schools because that's safe. And like its instincts tell it not to, you know, be alone cuz you'll get eaten. And yeah, that's like true. And that's, you know, we need that kind of basis to be able to make these conclusions about animal sentience, but I'm also curious if it's just like, what if that's also like, what if it's depressed not only because of like evolution, um, telling it to, it's safer to be around people or fish, but because it's an individual with sentience and it's lonely. Like how I would be if I was kept in a bowl. Um, and so I think things like that are really interesting and especially with like, uh, fish and, um, especially with like elasmobranchs, like shark, like a lot of shark species. Um, we automatically assume they have this like reptilian brain, but I'm very curious about challenging that.
Natalie Stockdale (Host) · 39:39
Yes. Yes. Fascinating. Katherine, how has spending long periods of time in the field with animals changed you as a person?